U.S. Entity Structures Explained: LLC vs. C-Corp for Canadian Business Owners

For Canadian companies expanding into the U.S., choosing the right entity structure is one of the most important, and most overlooked, decisions you’ll make. The wrong choice can expose you to double taxation, increase compliance costs, and limit your ability to reinvest profits where they matter most.

While the U.S. Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a favorite among domestic business owners, it often creates costly tax mismatches for Canadian owners. In many cases, a U.S. C-Corporation offers a more tax-efficient, compliant, and scalable solution. At Lodder CPA, we’ve seen too many businesses make an early structural decision that later costs them hundreds of thousands in unnecessary taxes.

This guide breaks down the differences, explains why LLCs are often problematic in cross-border scenarios, and outlines how to select the structure that supports your business goals.

Why LLCs Are So Common in the U.S.

The Limited Liability Company (LLC) is the default choice for many American entrepreneurs because it blends liability protection with tax simplicity. For U.S. residents, it’s often the most efficient structure available.

How it works for U.S. owners:

1. Single-member LLC – Treated as a “disregarded entity.” The IRS doesn’t require a separate corporate tax return, and all profits are reported directly on the owner’s personal return.
2. Multi-member LLC – Treated as a partnership. The LLC files an informational return, but profits are allocated to each member and taxed at their individual rates.

For domestic businesses, this pass-through treatment avoids corporate double taxation and keeps administrative costs low. But what works for an American business owner can have the opposite effect for a Canadian one — and that’s where specialized cross-border tax advice is essential.

The Canada–U.S. Tax Mismatch: Where Double Taxation Creeps In

The same LLC structure that works so well for U.S. entrepreneurs creates serious tax friction for Canadians.

Here’s the core issue:

1. In the U.S. – You pay tax at the individual level when the LLC earns income.
2. In Canada – The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) treats that LLC as a corporation, not a pass-through entity. Income is taxed at the corporate level in Canada only when distributed as dividends to the shareholder.

This creates a timing mismatch. The U.S. taxes the owner when the money is earned, but Canada taxes them when it’s distributed — and since these are considered two different “taxable events,” the CRA typically denies the foreign tax credit. The outcome is double taxation, with effective rates that can climb as high as 50–75%, depending on the provinces and states involved.

At Lodder CPA, we help clients avoid (or correct) this problem before it erodes profitability. We design structures that both countries recognize consistently, preventing unnecessary tax drag and compliance headaches.

The Hidden Risk of “Easy” Setup

The simplicity of forming an LLC in the U.S. — often in less than a day and at low cost — is exactly what lures Canadian entrepreneurs into trouble. Many either follow U.S.-based advisors’ recommendations or set up the entity themselves without realizing the treaty and compliance implications.

Restructuring later is possible but can be costly and disruptive, especially if the business already has U.S. revenue, contracts, or intellectual property tied to the LLC.

The C-Corporation: Often a Better Cross-Border Fit

In many cases, a U.S. C-Corporation offers better alignment between Canadian and U.S. tax rules:

1. Both countries treat it as a corporation.
2. Income is taxed in the U.S. when earned, then again in Canada when distributed.
3. Foreign tax credits can typically be applied, avoiding double taxation.

A C-Corp structure is especially effective for businesses planning to:

1. Scale U.S. operations
2. Reinvest profits in the American market
3. Hire U.S. employees
4. Attract U.S. investors
5. Prepare for a future sale or public offering

While it’s not the best choice for every scenario, a C-Corp often provides cleaner tax coordination, predictable reporting, and long-term planning flexibility. That said, the C-Corp is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The right choice depends on your ownership structure, operational model, exit goals, and where you plan to hold profits. Lodder CPA works with business owners to assess operational models, growth timelines, and shareholder objectives before recommending a structure.

Beyond Entity Type: Other Strategic Decisions

Choosing an LLC or C-Corp is only one piece of the puzzle. Your overall cross-border structure should be designed around your long-term goals. Key considerations include:

1. Ownership Structure – Should the U.S. entity be owned personally, by a Canadian corporation, or through a holding company?
2. State of Formation – Delaware isn’t always the right answer. Franchise taxes, reporting burdens, and local laws vary widely.
3. Equity Design – Planning to raise capital or incentivize employees? Structure equity with future growth in mind.
4. Growth Goals – Rapid expansion, steady growth, or short-term market entry all require different structures.
5. Cash Flow Planning – Will profits be reinvested, distributed, or retained? Tax treatment will differ.
6. Repatriation Strategy – Timing and method of bringing profits back to Canada can impact tax efficiency.
7. Intercompany Transactions – Transfer pricing, management fees, and IP arrangements must be set up carefully to meet compliance and minimize tax exposure.

Our team doesn’t just file forms, we take all of these factors into consideration and build the full blueprint so your U.S. presence supports your long-term profitability.

Final Takeaway: Structure to Win, Not Just to Start

Too many Canadian founders default to U.S. structures designed for domestic businesses only to discover years later that they’ve built in tax inefficiencies, compliance headaches, and barriers to growth. The result? Double taxation, trapped profits, and missed opportunities for reinvestment.

The good news is these problems are preventable. With Lodder CPA’s cross-border expertise, your U.S. entity can be a strategic asset in protecting margins, simplifying compliance, and positioning your business for long-term success.

Need to build or fix your U.S. structure?

At Lodder CPA, we specialize in designing and restructuring U.S. entities for Canadian businesses, aligning tax efficiency with growth objectives and cleaning up costly missteps.

Book a consultation and let’s create a structure that supports your end game, whether you're starting fresh or repairing the foundation.

‍